Police Trawling of Care homes
The practice of police trawling has been heavily criticised,
not least by the Home Affairs Select Committee. In 2002 they published
their report into the use of trawling for evidence. Now carried
out widely by police forces across the UK, it increased in popularity
following extensive trawling operations in Wales.
The report is available online via the following link:
http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200102/cmselect/cmhaff/836/83602.htm
The report highlighted particular aspects of police trawling
which are tailor-made to producing false allegations:
? Persistent approaches by police officers until a potential
witness agrees to make a complaint.
? The availability of compensation being discussed with a potential
witness early in an investigation.
? Failure to follow-up or record other lines of inquiry.
All of the recommendations that the Committee made which could
have removed the current imbalance in justice that we see in abuse
investigations have never been acted upon.
Instead, we continue to see investigations balanced in favour
of an alleged victim, with increasing measures to protect them.
What they are being protected from more than anything, is not
the accused, identification in the media nor the public.
Those making allegations are being protected from appreciating
the consequences of their allegations, and the responsibility
that comes with making them.
It must be remembered also that the establishments and institutions
which are most often targeted for trawling operations by police
are not, and should not be considered to be, 'children's homes'.
As with Kerelaw, these establishments house some of the most disturbed
and damaged young people in our society. They suffer from serious
behavioural problems and these are often combined with drug misuse
and abuse suffered at home.
Most of these people do not adjust to society easily, some never.
Some remain 'career criminals' with a deep disregard and disrespect
for others. For these, making such serious allegations against
another in exchange for financial reward is not likely to cause
them any concern.
Further essential reading:
The Secret of Bryn Estyn, by Richard Webster, published by Orwell
Press, ISBN: 09515922 4 6
www.orwellpress.co.uk
www.richardwebster.net/howthepolicetrawltheinnocent.html
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2003/02/20/nabus20.xml
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2003/02/19/nfals19.xml
Report on former care home resident who admitted making claim
to get compensation
www.insidetime.org/FebArticles/policetrawling.htm
www.factuk.org/Page143.aspx
www.innocent.org.uk/misc/carers2.html
www.coeffic.demon.co.uk/commons_select_committee.htm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/archive/1031559.stm
'In the name of the children', Panorama program aired on Sunday
Nov 26 2000.
Links to transcript of program and viewers comments