Histeria does not help any one and has been proved through out
the years to be the detriment to true justice, just think of the
birmingham 6. Read on and you will find a review of a book about
Robert E Bartholomew and Hilary Evans: Panic
Attacks
Reviewed by Roy Everett
We have all heard of the famous mass panic caused by the 1936
CBS broadcast in the USA of a radio adaptation of HG Wells' The
War of the Worlds, and the incident (including Orson Welles' comments)
is outlined as one chapter of this book, which begins by setting
out in chronological order a selection of other incidents of hoaxes,
mass panic and delusions in the past few centuries. The incidents
cover both hoaxes (where an individual sets out to temporarily
to fool the public knowing the story to be true) and mass hysteria
(where there is no initial intent to spread false alarm); at the
end of the book you realise that the effects are similar even
if the motives are different. However, these historical delusions
are by way as preamble for the author brings up to date with arguably
one of the most devastating and long-lasting mass delusions to
have spread around the USA and later the UK in the twentieth-century:
the belief that children's care homes across both countries have
been penetrated by supposed `paedophile rings', practitioners
of `ritual satanic child abuse', that a huge fraction of the child
population are the `victims' of family incest and sexual abuse,
and that this inevitably results in `psychological scars' in adulthood
which can be healed only by years of therapy and litigation.
As you read this book, your mind will gradually change as you
are reminded of past incidents and discover ones that you never
knew of: the 1630 Milan phantom terrorist poisoning, the hoax
reporting of Locke's animals and humanoids on the moon, the 1906
Halley's Comet poisoning, the 1992 UK BBC Ghostwatch scare, the
post-9/11 terrorism paranoia. You will start out mocking the gullibility
or tendency to hysteria of past generations and feeling smug that
nobody would fall this sort of thing again. However, as the events
move from mediaeval times to the present, especially if they are
within the timespan of your own memory and within your own country,
the smugness gives ways to unease as the authors point out that
you, too, fell under the same delusion or for the same hoax, even
if for only a short time. By the end of the book you may well
be seriously questioning whether what you hold to be a well-known
fact is delusional.
Finally you will reach the New American Witchhunt panic which
swept across the USA in the eighties (Rush-Herman-MacKinnon),
and diffused into the UK in the nineties (Rantzen-Campbell-Dawson-Waterhouse).
Indeed in some influential quarters it was still regarded as fact
well into the 2000s, despite being repeatedly demonstrated, latterly
in the UK by Richard Webster [1], to be the product of the interaction
of unsupportable psychiatric theories, religious anti-satanic
revivalism, a smattering of marxist-feminist political agenda,
media hype, compensation-seeking and an amazing credulousness
on the part of the public, policiticians, doctors and social workers.
After this book, one is left wondering if Rantzen is perhaps the
new Welles.
The authors are thorough in setting these stories in the context
of the age, so that we can begin to understand the collective
consciousness that provided the fertile ground which nurtured
these delusions at the time but seems bizarre nowadays. A recurring
theme they put across is first that the media are to blame by
sacrificing diligence and objectivity in the interests of increasing
programme ratings, celebrity status, newspaper circulation (and,
I presume, webhits and psychotherapist pension funds), and secondly
that they are reckless in perpetrating deliberate hoaxes on the
gullible public. A secondary balancing theme is that it does no
harm in the long term to society to have occasional mass hoaxes
and mass delusions to remind us of how gullible the human race
is to irrational behaviour in spite of --- or perhaps because
of ---- the rapidly increasing speed at which we can spread information
--- or disinformation. [1] The Secret of Bryn Estyn by Richard
Webster. The Orwell Press. Oxford, UK. ISBN 0 9515922 4 6. £25.00.
Panic Attacks by Robert E Bartholomew and Hilary Evans. Published
by Sutton Publishing, Gloucestershire, UK. 2004. ISBN 0-7509-3785-8.
£20.00